MainSocietyPhilosophyPhilosophical Anthropology › Autonomy in Determinism - Paideia Project

Autonomy in Determinism - Paideia Project

Edit Page
Report
Scan day: 02 February 2014 UTC
-121
Virus safety - good
Description: Article by Dieter Wandschneider attempting to show that determinism and autonomy are compatible.
20th WCP: Autonomy in Determinism Philosophisches Institut der RWTH Aachen (Germany) There are good reasons for determinism — the option for pure freedom of will proves to be a non-tenable position. However, this collides with the everyday experience of autonomy. The following argument will attempt to show that determinism and autonomy are compatible. (1) A first consideration going back to MacKay makes clear that I myself cannot foresee in principle my own determination; hence fatalism has lost its grounds. (2) From the perspective of physical determination, I show that quantum-physical indetermination is not at all in a position to explain autonomy, while from the perspective of systems theory physical determination and autonomy is well-compatible. (3) The possibility of knowledge denotes a further increase of such autonomy. From this perspective, acting is something like designing-oneself or choice-of-oneself. (4) Consciousness of not being fixed in principle now becomes a determining condition of my acting, which appears to be determined by autonomy. This explains the ineradicable conviction that freedom of will is essential for human beings. (5) I conclude that the autonomy of acting is greater the more that rational self-determination takes the place of stupid arbitrariness.
Size: 1310 chars

Contact Information

Phone&Fax:
Address:
Extended:

WEBSITE Info

Page title:20th WCP: Autonomy in Determinism
Keywords:
Description:
IP-address:128.197.26.3

WHOIS Info

NS
Name Servers: EDNS01.BU.EDU 128.197.253.182 EDNS02.BU.EDU 168.122.254.62
WHOIS
Date
activated: 25-Mar-1986
last updated: 21-May-2013
expires: 31-Jul-2014